YUKON COUNCIL ON THE ECONOMY AND THE ENVIRONMENT

Minutes of October 30 and 31, 1998

Yukon Inn - Northern Nook
Whitehorse, Yukon

 

Members Present:

Jennifer MauroChair
Daryn LeasCouncil of Yukon First Nations (Oct. 31)
Dave AustinYukon Chamber of Mines
Louise RangerYukon Federation of Labour
Andy WilliamsYukon Conservation Society
Ralph NordlingMember at Large
Kathy WatsonAssociation of Yukon Communities
John CarrollYukon Chamber of Commerce (Oct. 31)

Secretariat:

Toby SangerSecretariat, Executive Council Office
Karen SparrowSecretariat, Economic Development
Janet MoodieADM, Economic Development (Oct. 31 morning)

Regrets:

Louise BouvierYukon Indian Women's Association
George JohnsonCouncil of Yukon First Nations
Lucy van OldenbarneveldYukon Status of Women's Council

Guest Presenters:

Ross BurnettActing Manager, Policy Analysis and Development, Renewable Resources
Yvonne HarrisManager, Planning and Resource Policy, Renewable Resources
Thom StubbsDeputy Forest Commissioner, Yukon Forest Commission
Bill KlassenDeputy Commissioner, Development Assessment Process Commission

Guest:

Skeeter WrightSenior Analyst, Development Assessment Process Commission

 

1. Meeting Agenda

The Amended Draft Agenda was approved as written.

2. Approval of Minutes

3. Forest Strategy

Yukon Forest Commission staff presented an overview of the newly released Yukon Forest Strategy. This included a summary of the workshops and the process involved in finalizing the Strategy. The following were discussed in relation to the Strategy:

Council advised the Commission of their concern regarding First Nations' lack of concurrence with the Strategy. Council felt this issue should be rectified and partnerships restored in the implementation of the Forest Strategy.

ACTION: A letter shall be written to the Forest Commission providing the Council's comments.

4. Revisions to the Yukon Conservation Strategy (YCS)

Renewable Resources staff advised the Council that the next revision to the YCS is due for tabling in the fall 1999 Legislature.

Three options were presented to the Council for the revision to the Strategy. They included:

Council recommended the following:

Council requested funding from Renewable Resources to assist in implementing action.

ACTION: The Working Group will meet with Renewable Resources staff and complete a plan of action for presentation at the next meeting.

5. Yukon Conservation Strategy Review of Government's Implementation for 1998

Renewable Resources staff explained the legislated requirement of the Review and advised that it will be tabled in the Legislature in fall 1999.

ACTION: Renewable Resources staff will contact the Council to begin the Review.

6. YCEE Regulations

Renewable Resources Staff staff reviewed the documentation of comments received during the public review process. No substantive changes will be made to the draft regulations. The Department of Justice will inform Renewable Resources staff of a decision on the suggestions; regulations will then proceed to Cabinet.

7. YCEE Operating Procedures

Secretariat presented the finalized Operating Procedures to the Council. Secretariat explained that they were written to be generic and of use to other boards and councils. This process will assist them by having a precedent to follow and, hopefully, reduce some of the legwork that was involved in formulating our operating procedures.

Council was advised that the Operating Procedures could be revised at any time.

ACTION: Secretariat will forward our Operating Procedures to other boards and councils.

8. Development Assessment Process (DAP) Presentation

Development Assessment Process Commission staff presented the Council with an overview of the Development Assessment Process (DAP) and advised that a draft document has been completed. The Commission is now conducting public consultations, which will be completed in December. DAP is scheduled to be tabled federally in February 1999.

The purposes of DAP were reviewed. Council discussed the appeal process, timelines, duplication with Fisheries and Oceans and the Water Board, and mining applications.

The Council ended the session with confusion around the table particularly on the "gray" areas to be assessed. In light of the confusion, Council was unable to comment at this time. Council decided they wanted more details and to develop a better understanding of DAP before commenting.

ACTION: A meeting will be arranged for Council to meet with DAP representatives (Federal, YTG and First Nations) in November. Following that meeting comments from the Council will be prepared.

9. 1998 State of the Environment Report

Renewable Resources staff staff presented a draft outline of the 1999 State of the Environment Report which will be completed in late 1999 or early 2000. Council was advised of the budget constraints being faced.

Renewable Resources staff proposed adding an additional "special focus" section this year. While the Council supported the concept, there was not agreement on having the special section on salmon. Other areas were discussed such as: fresh water fish, frogs, and caribou. However, without clear terms of purpose, it would just be a "most favourite issue" list.

Traditional knowledge and concern about losing this source of valuable information was also discussed. Different sources of traditional information and different ways for inclusion were discussed:

The Council reiterated the importance to ensure traditional knowledge is not an add-on and is integrated throughout the report.

ACTION: Renewable Resources staff will get back to the Council with an outline of the objectives and purpose of the "special focus". Council will make recommendations based on what is trying to be achieved with a "special focus".

10. YTG Economic Initiatives

Economic Development staff and Secretariat presented a summary of the job initiatives being planned by the government. The following topics, as per handout, were discussed including:

Once again, questions were raised regarding the source of and management of the money associated with the Immigrant Investors Fund. Members asked again whether a code of ethics had been developed for acquiring, management and distribution of the funds. Council was told some are done, others are being developed.

ACTION: Economic Development staff to provide copy of Code of Ethics and Guidelines associated with the Immigrant Investors Fund and follow-up with Yukon Housing Corporation regarding the Request for Purchase concern.

11. Community Consultations

The Council reviewed the memo prepared by the Chair outlining the meeting with the Government Leader as well as the working group's meetings. Discussion took place on the framework provided in the memo with the following additional points discussed:

The memo was accepted. The Council's mandate will be to provide information and create the setting for stimulating discussions among individuals not just once but on a continuous basis. Council agreed that it would be a day session broken into topics yet to be defined and will ensure there is a community specific agenda. Council will try to have a complete cross section of community people available at the forums and will work to involve Association of Yukon Communities, Yukon College, the Chambers, First Nations and the schools.

A Steering Committee was formed consisting of Jennifer Mauro, Kathy Watson, Dave Austin, John Carroll, Louise Ranger and Daryn Leas. The Steering Committee will hire a coordinator. Consultations will take place in March, April and May with a final report prepared in June 1999. Two Council members will attend each community consultation.

ACTION: Chair will prepare a job description and a draft budget.

12. Communication and Public Education

  1. Communication Strategy - budget implementation will be available for the next meeting. No questions or comments on the strategy.

  2. Website: is functional and the address is: http://www.yukonweb.yk.ca/community/ycee/

    Secretariat explained the links from the Yukon website and the Yukon Government page. Council members suggested additional links.

    ACTION: Secretariat will look into getting additional links and will include minutes, the annual report and the tax paper on the website.

  3. Pamphlet: the written material for the pamphlet was distributed for review. Council members were asked to advise Secretariat if they had any comments on the material distributed or photographs available that they felt would enhance the pamphlet.

  4. College Seminar Discussion: Council reviewed memo prepared by Chair advising that on December Chair advised that on December 1st a student-led session with Bob Jickling's Yukon College Environmental Perspectives class will be held.

    ACTION: Chair will send out a reminder to all closer to the date.

  5. Women's Circumpolar Conference: Council reviewed the memo prepared by the Chair which provided an update on the Circumpolar Women's Conference which is being planned for Whitehorse in November 1999. Council agreed a collaborative effort with other women's agencies and non-government organizations would be beneficial. Topics being considered: access to capital and Northern First Nation culture.

    ACTION: Chair will keep Council informed.

  6. Public Speakers Series: Audrey McLaughlin will be speaking in Whitehorse December 3rd on the Vitality of the Circumpolar North. A community talk is being planned as well. Other topics suggested for the Speakers Series included:
  7. ACTION: Council will be reminded of date, time and place.

13. Administration

  1. The Annual Report: Approved, pending comments by November 4, 1998, on the basis that comments received do not change the substance of the report.

  2. Representation on Internal/Other Government Advisory Boards: The Chair raised the question of whether YCEE should have representation on other advisory bodies or groups at the request of government departments. Council felt their requests were not part of the existing or historical mandate. Council decided it would be possible if not more appropriate for Council to review a draft of the product to assist in providing a broad perspective. Since Council works on a consensus position basis, it would be a great strain and cost to develop consensus positions for representatives to take.

    ACTION: It was agreed that a letter would be written by Secretariat to inform the Anti-Poverty Board, Agricultural & Grazing Policy Board and the Tax Reform Board that the Council will not appoint individual YCEE members to represent the Council on their Boards.

  3. Press Release: Secretariat will prepare a press release from this meeting.

14. Next Meeting

Special Council meeting on DAP planned for November 20, 1998. Secretariat will coordinate and advise Council of the time and location. Consensus was reached to have the next general Council meeting at the end of January or the beginning of February 1999. It will be held in Haines Junction. Secretariat will coordinate and advise Council members.

Meeting adjourned at 3:15 P.M.

 

______________________________________

Jennifer Mauro, Chair